An investigation into adhesives to consolidate distemper paintings on canvas
Abstract
This article investigates traditional and modern adhesives used to consolidate distemper paintings on canvas, with special reference to sixteenth century Hispano-tüchlein paintings, also called sargas. Such artworks are not only difficult to handle due to their large size, but they are also inherently fragile and/or are highly hygroscopic. This sensitivity is caused in part by the nature of the painting technique as well as the lack of varnish, which might account for why conservation methods related to these works have not been addressed in the past. This investigation was conducted on historical reconstructions samples to assess and develop treatment strategies for distemper paintings, in particular issues linked to powdery/friable matte paint layers. The impact of several adhesives on the painted surface of historical reconstructions was evaluated before and after the samples were subjected to humidity cycling tests using a range of analytical techniques. Such information can be used to aid conservators who face consolidation issues related to underbound paintings or artworks with similar surfaces. The results reveal that there is no one perfect adhesive for matte paint nor one that can be removed completely, once applied. Aquazol® 200 and Funori performed the best, but still introduced changes in colour and gloss, even if minimal.
Downloads
References
APPELBAUM, B. (2007). Conservation Treatment Methodology, Oxford: Elsevier.
ANDRINA, E. (2014). ‘Potentiality of Funori to restore physical breaks of deteriorated cellulosic fibers’, CeROArt [accessed 21 October 2016]. Available at: http://ceroart.revues.org/3899.
ARSLANOGLU, J. (2003). ‘Evaluation of the Use of Aquazol as an Adhesive in Paintings Conservation’, Western Association for Art Conservation Newsletter, May, vol. 25, no. 2:12-18.
ARSLANOGLU, J. (2004). ‘Aquazol as Used in Conservation Practice’ Western Association for Art Conservation 26, 1 January, 10-15.
ARSLANOGLU, J. (2005). ‘Using Aquazol: A Brief Summary’, American Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works Paintings Specialty Group Postprints 17:107-110.
BOMFORD, D., ROY, A. & SMITH, A. (1986). ‘The Techiques of Dieric Bouts: Two Paintings Contrasted’, National Gallery Technical Bulletin, Vol 10:39-57.
BORREGO DÍAZ, P., BUCES AGUADO, J. A. & CARRASCO DAMIÁN, S. (2001). ‘Proceso de Conservación del aguazo “Oración en el Huerto”, Pátina, II, Nº 10: 4-11.
BUCES AGUADO, J. A. 2001. ‘La sarga y el aguazo: dos técnicas pictóricas a examen’, Revista Pátina, Vol. 10-11, Madrid: Escuela Superior de Conservación y Restauración de Bienes Culturales, pp. 58-70.
BUCES AGUADO, J. A., AHIJÓN PRADO, M. J., CEÑAL GONZÁLEZ-FIERRO, A., LLORCA GARRIGÓS, C., MANZANARES ORTIZ, C., RETANA GARRIDO, C., & YAÑEZ VINARDELL, M. C. (1992). ‘La Virgen y San Gabriel. Criterios de intervención de dos sargas de la Iglesia parroquial de San Pedro de Ávila’, IX Congreso de Conservación y Restauración de Bienes Culturales, Sevilla, 557-570.
BRUQUETAS GALÁN, R. (2002). Técnicas y materiales de la pintura española en los siglos de oro, Madrid: Fundación de Apoyo a la Historia del Arte Hispánico.
CALVO, A., RODRÍGUEZ DE AUSTRIA, L. & MANSO, B. (2002) ‘Nuevas Aportaciones al Estudio de las Técnicas en la Pintura de Sargas (La Sarga de Santa Ana de la Iglesia Parroquial de Madarcos de la Sierra, (Madrid)’, actas del I Congreso del GEIIC Valencia, 449-454.
CASTELL AGUSTÍ, M. (2002). ‘Antecedentes Históricos y Técnicos del Soporte Textil: Las Sargas o Tüchlein. El Caso de los Telones Cuaresmales en la Iglesia de San Lucas Evangelista de Cheste (Valencia). Estudio Técnico, Analítico y Estado de Conservación’, Actas del XIV Congreso de Conservación y Restauración de Bienes Culturales, Valladolid, 503-512.
CASTELL AGUSTÍ, M., MARTÍN REY, S. & FUSTER LÓPEZ, L. (2006) ‘Sargas o Tüchlein: Particularidades Técnicas y Alteraciones Frecuentes’, Arché, Instituto Universitario de Restauración de la UPV, Num. 1, Valencia, 79-86.
CATENAZZI, K. (2016). ‘Evaluation of the use of Funori for consolidation of powdering paint layers in wall paintings’, Studies in Conservation, March 2016.
COLOMBO, A., TASSONE, F., MAURI, M., SALERMO, D., DELANEY, J.K., PALMER, M. R., DE LA RIE, R., & SIMONUTTI, R. (2012). ‘Highly transparent nanocomposite films from water-based poly (2-ethyl-2-oxazoline)/TiO2 dispersions’, RSC Advances, 2:1-9.
COLOMBO, A., GHERARDI, F., GOIDANICH, S., DELANEY, J. K., DE LA RIE, E. R., UBALDI, M. C., TONIOLO, L. & SIMONUTTI, R. (2015). ‘Highly transparent poly (2-ethyl-2-oxazoline)-TiO2 nanocomposite coatings for the conservation of matte painted artworks’, RSC Advances, 103: 1-11.
DIGNARD, C., DOUGLAS, R., GUILD, S., MAHEUX, A. & MCWILLIAMS, W. (1997). ‘Ultrasonic Misting. Part 2, Treatment Applications’, Journal of the American Institute for Conservation, Vol. 36, No. 2 (Summer, 1997), 127-141.
EBERT, B., SINGER, B. & GRIMALDI, N. (2012). ‘Aquazol as a consolidant for matte paint on Vietnamese paintings’, Journal of the Institute of Conservation, 35:1, 62-76.
FAN, T. F. (2012). ‘Evaluation of Funori Stability in Preparation Methods’. In: Barros, A., Bone, L., Clarricoates, R. & Ghent A. eds. Adhesives and Consolidants in Painting Conservation. London: Archetype Publications in association with the ICON Paintings Group, 53-60.
GARCÍA GÓMEZ-TEJEDOR, J. (1991). ‘Tratamiento de Conservación y Restauración’, in El retablo y la sarga de San Eutropio de El Espinar, Dirección General de Bellas Artes y Archivos, Instituto de Conservación y Restauración de Bienes Culturales, Madrid: Ministerio de Cultura, 166-170.
GEIGER, T. & MICHEL, F. (2005). ‘Studies on the Polysaccharide JunFunori Used to Consolidate Matt Paint’, Studies in Conservation, Vol. 50, No. 3 (2005), 193-204.
HANSEN, E. F. & LOWINGER, R. (1990). ‘Investigations into Techniques for the Consolidation of High pigment Volume Concentration paint at the Getty Conservation Institute’, Western Association for Art Conservation Newsletter, Vol. 12, No 3, September, 13-16.
HANSEN, E. F., LOWINGER, R. & SADOFF, E. (1993). ‘Consolidation of Porous Paint in a Vapour-Saturated Atmosphere. A Technique for Minimizing Changes in the Appearance of Powdering, Matte Paint’, Journal of the American Institute for Conservation, Vol. 32, No. 1 (Spring), 1-14.
HANSEN, E. F., S, WALSTON, & M. H. BISHOP (1993). Matte Paint: Its History and Technology, Analysis, Properties, and Conservation Treatment with Special Emphasis on Ethnographic Objects, Getty Conservation Institute in association with the International Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works (IIC), London.
HESS, D., AND ESER, T., (2012). Der Frühe Dürer, Nurenberg: Ausstellung im Germanischen Nationalmuseum vom 24. Mai bis 2.
HORIE, C.V. (2012). Materials for Conservation, Oxford: Butterworth & Co.
LA NASA, J., DI MARCO, F., BERNAZZANI, L., DUCE, C., SPEPI, A., UBALDI, V., DEGANO, I., ORSINI, S., LEGNAIOLI, S., TIN, M. R., DE LUCA, D., & MODUGNO, F. (2017).” Aquazol as a binder for retouching paints. An evaluation through analytical pyrolusis and thermal analysis”, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 144, Elsevier, 508-519.
LECHUGA, K. (2009). ‘Aquazol as a Heat Set Adhesive for Textile Conservation Treatments’, American Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Textile Specialty Group Postprints, 19:1-7.
LECHUGA, K. (2011). ‘Aquazol-Coated Remoistenable Mending Tissues’. In: CCI Symposium on Adhesives and Consolidants for Conservation: Research and Applications Proceedings, October, Canadian Conservation Institute, 1-14.
LEONARD, M., PREUSSER, F., ROTHE, A. & SCHILLING, M. (1988). ‘Dieric Bouts’s ‘Annunciation’. Materials and Techniques: A Summary’, The Burlington Magazine, Vol. 130, No. 1024 (July), 517-522.
LEVENFIELD LAREDO, C. (1992). ‘Las Pinturas sobre Anjeo o Sargas. Historia Material y Técnica’, in El retablo y la sarga de San Eutropio de El Espinar, Dirección General de Bellas Artes y Archivos, Instituto de Conservación y Restauración de Bienes Culturales, Madrid: Ministerio de Cultura, pp. 152-157.
MAHEUX, A. F. & MCWILLIANS, W. (1995). ‘The Use of Ultrasonic Mister for the Consolidation of a Flaking Gouache Painting on Paper’. In: The Book and Paper Group Specialty Group Session, Vol 14, The American Institute for Conservation 23th Annual Meeting, June 1-4, Minnesota [accessed 25 June 2017]. Available at: http://cool.conservation-us.org/coolaic/sg/bpg/annual/v14/bp14-03.html.
MICHALSKI, S. & DIGNARD, C. (1997). ‘Ultrasonic Misting. Part 1, Experiments on Appearance Change and Improvement in Bonding’, Journal of the American Institute for Conservation, Vol. 36, No. 2 (Summer, 1997), 109-126.
MICHALSKI, S., DIGNARD, C., VAN HANDEL, L. & ARNOLD, D. (1998). ‘The Ultrasonic Mister: Applications in the Consolidation of Powdery Paint on Wooden Artifacts’. In: Dorge, V. and Howlett, F. C. eds. Painted Wood: History and Conservation, Proceedings of a Symposium organized by the Wooden Artifacts group of the American Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works and the Foundation of the AIC, Williamsburg, 11-14 November, The Getty Conservation Institute Publications, 498-513.
MICHEL, F. (2011). ‘Funori and JunFunori: Two Related Consolidants with Surprising Properties’. In: Adhesives and Consolidants for Conservation: Research and Applications, Canadian Conservation Institute Symposium Proceedings, October, Ottawa, 1-15.
PACHECO, F. (1649). Arte de la pintura, Madrid: Ed. Cátedra (this edition 1990).
PALOMINO DE CASTRO Y VELASCO, A. (1715-1724) El Museo Pictórico y Escala Óptica, Vol I: Theorica de la Pintura, Madrid: Ed. Aguilar (this edition 1988).
RENARD GROSS, P., BUCES AGUADO, J. A. & FUSTER SABATER, M. D. 1991. ‘Camino del Calvario. Estudio y conservación de una sarga del Panteón Real de Oña (Burgos)’, Servicio Central de Publicaciones del Gobierno Vasco, Vitoria-Gasteiz, 579-612.
ROY, A. (1988) ‘The Technique of a ‘Tüchlein’ by Quinten Massys’, National Gallery Technical Bulletin, Vol 12:36-43.
SARTIANI, O., SEVERINI, L., ROMA, P. & CIATTI, M. (2010). ‘An Unusual Case of Integration and its Solution’. In: Ellison, Smithen & Turnbull eds. Mixing and Matching. Approaches to Retouching Paintings. London: Archetype.
SANTOS GÓMEZ, S. & SAN ANDRÉS MOYA, M. (2004). ‘La Pintura de Sargas’, Archivo Español de Arte, Tomo 77, nº 305, Madrid, 59-74.
SHARPE, E. (2016). ‘Restorers use Japanese algae and sturgeon glue to treat Futurist work. Giacomo Balla’s Automobile Speed + Light + Noise to go back on view in Zurich’, published in Journal The Art Newspaper [accessed 7 June 2017]. Available at: http://theartnewspaper.com/news/conservation/restorersusejapanesealgaeandsturgeongluetotreatfuturistwork/
SWIDER, J. R. & SMITH, M. (2005). ‘Overview of a 300-Year-Old Consolidant’, Journal of the American Institute for Conservation, Vol. 44, No. 2 (Summer, 2005), 117-126.
TOMASINI, E., SIRACUSANO, G., & MAIER, M. S. (2011). ‘Spectroscopic, Morphological and Chemical Characterization of Historic Pigments Based on Carbon. Paths for the Identification of an Artistic Pigment’, Microchemical Journal 102, May 2012, Elsevier, 28-37.
THUER, C. (2012). ‘Facing Adhesives for Size-tempera Painted Wood: Results of a Research Internship for Historic Scotland’. In: Barros D’Sa, A., Bone, L., Clarricoates, R. & Gent, A. eds. Adhesives and Consolidants in Painting Conservation. London: Archetype, 68-84.
VELIZ, Z. (1986). Artist’s Techniques in the Spanish Golden Age. Six Treatises, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
VON DER GOLTZ, M., BIRKENBEUL, I., HOROVITZ, I. BLEWETT, M. AND DOLGIKH, I. (2012). ‘Consolidation of Flaking Paint and Ground’. In: Hill Stoner, J and Rushfield, R. eds. Conservation of Easel Paintings. London: Routeledge, 369-383.
WATKINS, S. (2002). ‘Practical Considerations for Humidifying and Flattening Paper’, The Book and Paper Group Annual 21: 61-76.
WELSH, E. (1980). ‘A Consolidation Treatment for Powdery Matte Paint’, AIC Preprints of Papers Presented at the Eighth Annual Meeting, San Francisco, California, 22-25 May, 141-150.
WOLBERS, R., D. DUERBECK, & M. MCGINN (1998). ‘Poly (2-Ethyl-2-Oxazoline): A New Conservation Consolidant’. In: Dorge, V. & C. Howlett, C. ed. Painted Wood: History and Conservation. Los Angeles: The Getty Conservation Institute, 514-527.
WOLFTHAL, D. (1989). The Beginnings of Netherlandish Canvas Painting 1400-1530, Cambridge Univ. Press.
- Copyright and intellectual property belongs to author. Author guarantees editing and publishing rights to Ge-Conservación Journal, under a Creative Commons Attribution License. This license allows others to share the work with authorship and the original source of publication acknowledgement.
- Articles can be used for scientific and educational purposes but never for commercial use, being sanctioned by law.
- The whole content of the article is author’s responsibility.
- Ge-Conservación Journal and authors may establish additional agreements for non-exclusive distribution of the work version published at the Journal (for example, on institutional repositories or on a book) with acknowledgment of the original publication on this Journal.
- Author is allowed and encouraged to disseminate his works electronically (for example, on institutional repositories or on its own website) after being published on Ge-Conservación Journal. This will contribute for fruitful interchanges as also for wider and earlier citations of the author’s works.
- Author’s personal data will only be used for the Journal purposes and will not be given to others.
